5 STARS & SUPER CLASSIC status (meaning it has achieved brilliance in at least 5 vintages) in Michael Cooper's Buyer's Guide to New Zealand Wine, which rates wines according to quality and consistency.
Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate, USA:
"The flight of Pegasus Bay Pinot Noirs continued to illustrate their burgundy influence, the reds often reminiscent of Morey-saint-Denis."
Steve Tanzer, International Wine Cellar, USA:
"Felton Road, along with Pegasus Bay, has been my favourite Pinot producer in New Zealand for years."